Dimitry Ablogin Recital in the Orangerie , Darmstadt - 14th March 2025 - Chopin Gesellschaft in der BRD e.V.
As is always the case with this pianist, I am overcome with superlatives. He is one of the great period piano specialists but also has a commanding keyboard technique and deep musical insight that convinces completely on the modern instrument.
At the time I first heard him, I wrote of his playing:
Fryderyk Chopin (1810-1849)
Rondo
à la Mazur in F major Op.
5 (1825–26)
Mazurka de Chopin (1911) Edward Okuń (1872-1945)
This
work was written when Chopin was 16 (such a prodigious genius). He dedicated it
to the Countess Alexandrine de Moriolles, the daughter of the Comte de
Moriolles, who was the tutor to the adopted son of the Grand Duke Constantine,
Governor of Warsaw.
This
rather unpleasant individual often requested Chopin to play for him at the
Belvedere Palace. Unable to sleep, on winter nights he would ostentatiously
send a sleigh drawn by four-horses harnessed abreast in the Russian style to
collect the young pianist from his home. Schumann first heard the Rondo
à la mazur in 1836, and he called it '...lovely, enthusiastic
and full of grace. He who does not yet know Chopin had best begin the
acquaintance with this piece'.
This
piece was written when Chopin was 16. He dedicated it to the Countess
Alexandrine de Moriolles, the daughter of the Comte de Moriolles, who was the
tutor to the adopted son of the Grand Duke Constantine, Governor of Warsaw.
This rather unpleasant individual often requested Chopin to play for him at the
Belvedere Palace. Unable to sleep, on winter nights he would ostentatiously
send a sleigh drawn by four-horses harnessed abreast in the Russian style to
collect the young pianist from his home. Schumann first heard the Rondo
à la mazur in 1836, and he called it 'lovely, enthusiastic and
full of grace. He who does not yet know Chopin had best begin the acquaintance
with this piece'.
Ablogin
invested the work with the grace, youthful exuberance and elegance one could
imagine from the Chopin universe allied with his ebullient youthful personality
at the time. Ablogin created an intimate ambiance common among the original
cultivated audience yet contrasted with intense imaginative expressiveness. The transparency of his playing never omits often unnoticed contrapuntal lines in Chopin often submerged by melody in less distinguished performances. The
range of colour, touch, tone, rubato and phrasing transported us into another
world of more balanced sensibility to the present. Quite wonderful, even
magical.
Learned,
rather conventional emotional expressive gestures rather than spontaneous
reactions to the musical context were mercifully absent. Ablogin brought charm,
style, élan and panache to this work which his relatively light touch created le
climat de Chopin (the words of Marcelina Czartoryska, Chopin's finest
pupil). Here we have as a young, carefree, Polish
adolescent with character and personality plus, wit, humour, theatrics - a
young man striving to please with his massively precocious talent.
A
few observations on the mazurka as a genre are appropriate in view of the
'Mazurka Fever' gripping musical Europe and Russia at the time.
The
mazurka is the quintessential expression of the Polish national and ethnic
identity. Any approach to them is bound to cause comment, sometimes dismissive,
sometimes abrasive but never indifferent or detached. One should examine
the nature of dancing in Warsaw during the time of Chopin. Almost half of his
music is actually dance music of one sort or another and a large proportion of
the rest of his compositions contain dances.
Dancing
was a passion especially during carnival from Epiphany to Ash Wednesday. It was
an opulent time, generating a great deal of commercial business, no less than
in Vienna or Paris. Dancing - waltzes, polonaises, mazurkas - were a vital part
of Warsaw social life, closely woven into the fabric of the city. The dancers
were not restricted to noble families - the intelligentsia and
bourgeoisie also took part in the passion.
Chopin's
experience of dance, as a refined gentleman of exquisite manners, would have
been predominantly urban ballroom dancing with some experience of peasant
hijinks during his summer holidays in Żelazowa Wola, Szafania and elsewhere.
Poland was mainly an agricultural society in the early nineteenth
century. At this time Warsaw was an extraordinary melange of cultures.
Magnificent magnate palaces shared muddy unpaved streets with dilapidated
townhouses, szlachta farms, filthy hovels and teeming markets.
By
1812 the Napoleonic campaigns had financially crippled the Duchy of Warsaw.
Chopin spent his formative years during this turbulent political period and the
family often escaped the capital to the refuge of the Mazovian countryside at
Żelazowa Wola. Here the fields are alive with birdsong, butterflies and
wildflowers. On summer nights the piano was placed in the garden and Chopin
would improvise eloquent melodies that floated through the orchards and across
the river to the listening villagers gathered beyond.
Of
course he was a perfect mimic, actor, practical joker and enthusiastic dancer
as a young man, tremendously high-spirited. He once wrote a verse describing
how he spent a wild night, half of which was dancing and the other half playing
pranks and dances on the piano for his friends. They had great fun! One of his
friends took to the floor pretending to be a sheep! On one occasion he even
sprained his ankle he was dancing so vigorously! He would play with gusto and
'start thundering out mazurkas, waltzes and polkas'.
When
tired and wanting to dance, he would pass the piano over to 'a humbler
replacement'. Is it surprising his teacher Józef Elzner and his doctors advised
a period of 'rehab' at Duszniki Zdrój to preserve his health which had already
begun to show the first signs of failing? This advice may not have been the
best for him or his sister Emilia and Ludwika Skarbek, as reinfection was
always a strong possibility there. Both were dead tired not long after their
return from the so-called 'cure'.
Many
of his mazurkas would have come to life on the dance floor as improvisations. Ablogin
made much use of interpolated ornaments perfectly in period character. Perhaps
only later were they committed to the more permanent art form on paper under
the influence and advice of the Polish folklorist and composer Oskar Kolberg.
Chopin floated between popular and art music quite effortlessly.
George
Sand wrote in Les Maîtres Sonneurs (The Master Pipers) 'He
gave us the finest dances in the world....so attractive and easy to dance to
that we seemed to fly through the air.'
Dimitry Ablogin assembled this
programme with great care and thought, as always. His adventurous, exploratory
approach was tastefully evident throughout this recital. One aspect of his
deeply personal and therefore truly authentic performance was obvious in his
introduction and revivification of the art of 'preluding'. The practice of
'preluding' music pieces was common in the Baroque period, the period of
Classicism even extending to Romanticism. Such a type of prelude is a
short piece of improvised musical introduction to the key and character of the
piece which will be subsequently performed. Ablogin also resuscitated the
improvisatory practice of augmentation of decorative fiorituras and
ornaments into the notated score in a movingly expressive manner. This practice
was often mentioned by Chopin himself in his lessons and letters. It was also
occasionally frustratingly illustrated in his many last minute
adjustments to the printed publisher score, even before the ink was dry!
The conception and varied
acceptance of the Chopin Nocturne, which as a genre, is of
particularly significant interest in terms of current gender concerns and
preoccupations. The broader operatic vocal song and vocal repertoires for the
Parisian salon were immensely popular in Warsaw at this time and influenced the
piano composition of many romances and nocturnes.
Nocturnes were nearly always concerned with the
'feminine' in Chopin's day, as playing the piano was predominantly a female
'accomplishment'. It is estimated that one in five ladies played the instrument
as an attractive talent in the Paris of the mid nineteenth century. In
addition, such qualities and talents appeared fictionally in the novels of Jane
Austen in order to lure financially comfortable suitors. As such music was
considered a love song, their romantic atmosphere often derived from poetic
duets sung in opera by soprano and tenor or two sopranos. Chopin often
punctuated such emanations with messianic military marches, hymns and laments.
My conception, possibly founded
in later psychological research and discovery, is a personal conviction that
much of the music of Chopin is based on a rich, inspired balance and contrast
achieved between the male and female aspects of human character. In his own
music, Robert Schumann also clarified this contrast more directly in his
transparent creation of the characters of Florestan and Eusebius residing in
his own psyche.
The Nocturne in B
major was composed in Vienna in 1831. It illustrates the
profound psychological contrast and oscillation of mood in the unpredictable,
turbulent central section common to many of the Chopin Nocturnes.
Ablogin understood the conflicted
inner psychological turmoil of the work. First, at the outset, with a legato,
captivating undulating theme reminiscent of a barcarolle and the
suggestion of waves on a lagoon, a domain often associated with night and love.
The enchanting melody is simple, like a song with figuration that Ablogin
enhanced in a poignant manner. The agitato mood that fills the
middle section of the Nocturne erupts frighteningly and suddenly to disappear
just as precipitously.
The section is certainly without
feminine cliché, almost menacing and warlike. Ablogin's glorious variation of
colour, tone and timbre reflect such changes, as does his interpolation of
tastefully improvised fiorituras and augmented decoration. The
section combines the march rhythms of possibly, dare I say, 'masculine'
insurrectionary song. Any resemblance to a Nocturne by John
Field or his supposed influence on Chopin, has been erased.
Nocturne F sharp minor Op.
48/2
This Nocturne was
written in 1841in my favourite key of F sharp minor. When Chopin was
teaching his pupil, the rather muscular Adolf Gutmann, he spoke of the middle
section of this work in dramatic terms reminiscent of French Grand Opera: 'A
tyrant commands, and the other asks for mercy.' It begins with a
reflective, lyrical song that Ablogin set in an atmosphere of the dream
with expressive perfection.
‘What is most exquisite and
most individual in Chopin’s art, wherein it differs most wonderfully from all
others,’ noted André Gide
in his illuminating text Notes on Chopin, tr. Bernard Frechtman
(New York, 1949), p.41. ‘I see in just that non-interruption of the
phrase; the insensible, the imperceptible gliding from one melodic proposition
to another, which leaves or gives to a number of his compositions the fluid
appearance of streams.'
Again Ablogin emphasized the texture and colour of the middle section of this nocturne which brings a 'relentless, obsessive and dramatic repetition, in every way possible, of a single formula, confounding all continuity and coherence.' [Mieczysław Tomaszewski]
Felix Mendelssohn-Bartholdy (1809-1847)
Piano
sonata Op. 6 (1826)
Felix Mendelssohn-Bartholdy in 1833
Felix
Mendelssohn was a virtuoso pianist born in 1809. Schumann was born in 1810, as
was Chopin, and Liszt followed this glowing caravan of creativity in 1811.
These were youthful pianist-composers at a time when the piano was considered a
constantly evolving, rather a modern instrument. Beethoven commenced his career
in the 1790s as a virtuoso pianist.
Chopin
used to visit piano factories in Warsaw, such as the Polish firm Bucholtz,
obsessively following new technical developments in the role of what we might
now call an 'early adopter'. Composers such as Hummel, Moscheles (a friend of
Mendelssohn), Kalkbrenner and Ries were tumultuously adored in a manner similar
to pop phenomena today such as Taylor Swift.
Mendelssohn's
early concertos are phenomenal works that place him directly beside Mozart in
precocity. The sonatas were precursors to the ‘mature’ style in works such as
the Rondo capriccioso and the Andante cantabile e
Presto agitato.
I
must confess to being unfamiliar with this work and was astounded by the
harmonic adventurism and sheer confident élan of the writing. One could feel a
sense of compositional exploration in many of the harmonies and Ablogin gave us
as fine an account as far as I could judge in this case-limited way. A
marvelous piece performed magnificently.
Mendelssohn
was among the first generation of musicians to experience and come to terms
with Beethoven’s complex late style. According to Robert Schumann, in his Piano
Sonata in E major Op 6 (1826) the seventeen-year-old Mendelssohn touched:
‘Beethoven
with his right hand, while looking up to him as to a saint, and being guided at
the other by Carl Maria von Weber (with whom it would be more possible to be on
a human footing)’.
Beethoven
was a most profound influence on this sonata especially in the cantabile style
of the opening phrases in the rather pastoral, zephyr-like first Allegretto
con espressione movement.
We
hear Beethoven's musical influence on Mendelssohn of the Beethoven ‘Archduke’
Piano Trio (1811) and also the Piano Sonata in A major, Op 101 (1816)
that especially fascinated the young Felix.
The
minuet second movement with a faster trio section leads directly into the
beautiful Adagio. Ablogin brought
an affecting and moving sensitivity to this third movement. The Finale is full
of youthful exuberance which Ablogin utilized expressively and fulsomely. Here,
we experienced the commanding keyboard virtuosity of Weber that informs the
tumultuous conclusion of the sonata. The slow movement ends with powerfully
repeated fortissimo chords and descending octaves, launching into the muscular Molto
Allegro e vivace last movement.
Structurally,
I feel the sonata is not as fluid with that sense of musical inevitability and
seamless flow that suffuses so many of Mendelssohn's piano compositions. He, in
fact, abandoned writing piano sonatas as an adult. Dimitry Ablogin, who loves
the music of Mendelssohn, gave us a fine, coherent and convincing account of
this youthful sonata of genius.
John Field (1782-1837)
Nocturne E Minor Op.10
Nocturne A major Op.4
The Moscow of John Field
Illumination in Sobornaya Square in Honour of Emperor Alexander
I's Coronation (c. 1802) Fyodor
Alekseyev
Among
early composers it was John Field who was famed for his nocturnes. Many lovers
were transported to sensual realms in salons by his lyricism. When Chopin wrote
works in this genre, he was naturally connected to Field, not least perhaps by
the associated Slavic nature of Chopin being Polish and Field living in Russia.
Although commonly associated in influence, it is clear in musical profundity
they are quite disparate in many respects. Chopin takes us to distant and deep
realms of emotional feeling and expression scarcely entered by Field.
The
term 'serenade' is sometimes given to Field's compositions in this genre and
sweetly seductive they are. However, the Polish composer and music critic Józef
Sikorski (1813-1896), writes penetratingly of the disparate nature in
comparison with Field:
'Chopin's
nocturnes, meanwhile, for the most part pictures on a dark background, spirits
flowing down to the earth at night, appear and disappear here mysteriously.
Fantasy in disarray leads us, in unfathomable phrases, as if in a dream from
object to object, from thought to thought. And as in a dram we succumb to a
force incomprehensible to us when awake...we follow him across the depths and
the heights; yielding to the magical sway, we comprehend the logic of feelings,
we understand the fantasy turned into reality...struggling to break free from
the power of the mysterious world to which the poet [Chopin] has
subjected us...'
[Józef
Sikorski 'Recollections of Chopin': The Earliest Essay on Chopin and His
Music taken from the remarkable book Chopin and his World Jonathan
Bellman and Halina Goldberg Ed p.70, Princeton 2017]
Yet,
listening to the extreme simplicity, refinement and economy of means in
these Field nocturnes played with much refinement by Ablogin, it is hardly
surprising that the aristocratically cultivated Chopin was seduced by them to
create his own augmented creations of the form. Field was well-known
in 19th-century Europe both as teacher and pianist.
Ablogin
fully comprehends this purposefully created intimate ambiance of the
nocturne and continued to reduce the audience to utter silence - a variety of
hypnotism in operation distinguished by the sheer quality of these beautiful,
intense, subtly ornamented cantabile melodies. Such a pity the
Field nocturnes are not better known for themselves and not simply as
shadows that influenced the immortal creations of Fryderyk Chopin.
Johann Nepomuk Hummel (1778 – 1837)
Piano Sonata in F sharp minor Op. 81
I.
Allegro
II.
Largo con molt'espressione
III. Vivace
I have been to the city of Weimar at least three times and consider it one of the most remarkable small cities in Europe, an ideological capital if you will, but now harbouring only the ghosts of Europe's squandered Enlightenment ideals. Ah, dearest Weimar ! What a history you have and as a city are such symbolic representation of Europe ! Surely, no small place has experienced such a concentration of resident musical (Bach, Anton Rubinstein, Schumann, Liszt, Mendelssohn, Richard Strauss) literary (Goethe, Schiller, the setting for the romantic novel Lotte in Weimar by Thomas Mann) and architectural genius (the Bauhaus movement) as well as attracting so many illustrious musical visitors.
The city had only a population of perhaps 12,000
souls when Liszt chose to live so scandalously
with Princess Carolyne Sayn-Wittgenstein at the Villa
Altenberg and teach at his renowned school in the town. Marlene
Dietrich even studied the violin in Weimar and became embroiled in a love
affair with her teacher. Then came the Weimar Republic, the calamity of the
Nazis and the Third Reich, the construction of their bombastic buildings and
ultimately Buchenwald...
Why do I mention Weimar in connection with this recital? Well, one of my favorite composers lived and worked there. Johann Nepomuk Hummel (1778 – 1837) was an Austrian composer and virtuoso pianist. His music reflects the transition from the Classical to the Romantic musical periods. He is an underestimated musical genius of the greatest inventiveness both in chamber music and piano concertos. At the age of eight, Hummel was taught and housed by Mozart for two years free of charge in Vienna. He made his first concert appearance at the age of nine with Mozart in Dresden (1787) in one of Mozart's concerts.
Hummel, among other distinguished positions in an incredibly distinguished career, held the position of Kapellmeister in Weimar from 1819 to 1837. He formed a close friendship with Goethe and read the poetry of Schiller, who also lived there but had died in 1805. During Hummel's stay in Weimar he made the city into a European musical capital, inviting the best musicians of the day to visit and perform. He brought one of the first musicians' pension schemes into existence and was one of the first musicians to agitate for musical copyright to combat intellectual piracy.
Hummel also had an incalculable influence on the style brillante of the early compositions by Fryderyk Chopin - the concertos and many variations, rondos and other solo works. He performed in Warsaw in 1828 to great acclaim, members of the audience standing on their chairs in order to better observe how he performed his famous trills. The composer developed a close relationship with Poles and admired the pianist Maria Szymanowska greatly.
Of all Hummel’s keyboard sonatas, the Sonata in F sharp
minor, Op 81 (1819) is highly adventurous suiting Ablogin's
temperament, as it inhabits the cusp of the Classical and Romantic. The Allgemeine
musikalische Zeitung reviewer found the work ‘meaningful,
noble, spirited, pathetic, skilful, logical, novel, and pianistically
resourceful to an extent truly deserving the term 'Grosse Sonate' and
making it the finest, also the most difficult, among all sonatas to date’.
The youthful Schumann in his letter to
Friedrich Wieck wrote perceptively:
'Ein wahrhaft großes, episches Titanenwerk und das Gemälde eines ungeheuren, ringenden, resignirten Geistes'
'A truly great, epic titanic work and the painting of a tremendous, struggling, resigned spirit…' (trans. Ablogin)
The Allegro first movement was wildly dramatic yet became reflective as if partaking of some tumultuous fantasy. Hummel’s con brio semiquaver runs in fourths and thirds must have been a challenge to pianists not only of his day but also of today! The slow Largo con molt’espressione opened unexpectedly not with a tender exhalation but fortissimo in anger. These romantic tempestuous explosions continued in a rather Chopinesque fashion but with less emotional depth and disturbance. The Vivace finale was rather folkloric in atmosphere but made quite fantastic demands on the technique of the performer. Hummel provides a blessed quiet fugal passage in what was a relentless drive to a sensational and exhilarating conclusion.
Needless to say, Ablogin rose to the occasion demanded
by this 'titanic' sonata with musical inspiration and comprehensive command of
the entire keyboard.
Hummel's grave in Weimar
Hummel was a chamber musician of the greatest genius evident in his own rarely performed chamber compositions. For a fine example of Hummel's fiery genius, I refer you to his glittering chamber ensemble transcription for piano, flute, violin and cello of Mozart's Symphony No.40 in G minor KV 550 (1788) composed just three years before his death. This transfiguring work, magically transformed by Hummel in 1824, is a graceful flight over a chiaroscuro landscape fluctuating between light and shade.
[The only detailed modern history of Weimar I know in any language is the magnificent Weimar: From Enlightenment to the Present by Michael H. Kater (Yale 2014)]
For an encore Ablogin gave us a superbly glittering style brillante account of the Mendelssohn Rondo capriccioso. This was followed by a moving, highly ornamented and varied augmentation of Chopin Nocturne in E flat major Op.9/2. For the Polish musicologist, critic and composer ZdzisÅ‚aw Jachimecki (1882-1953), this Nocturne is ‘an example of a rare sense of stylistic purity’.
The statement could surely be applied to this entire spiritually uplifting and musically rewarding recital by Dimitry Ablogin. In a time of tragic and scarcely comprehensible horrors of war, this creative expression in music was unutterably welcome.
** ** ** ** ** ** **
A highly recommended Chopin recording on Chopin's last Pleyel piano in Warsaw
by
Dimitry Ablogin
![]() |
NIFCCD 149 https://sklep.nifc.pl/en/produkt/77317-late-works-opp-45-64 My review of this CD http://www.michael-moran.com/2023/12/endymion-1818-john-keats-1795-1821.html |
Comments
Post a Comment